Thursday, 6 November 2025

I had no idea that St John's gospel is the only one that says Jesus is God

SHARE
My ignorance of my own religion is shameful. I would not usually read anything by Mrs Pagel, a modish American academic who wrote a best-selling book about the Gospel of Thomas and chafes at the patriarchy of Christianity, but this passage in an interview with her is very interesting.

<But isn’t the teaching that Jesus is the only Son of God in all the gospels, not just John?
That’s what I thought, and most Christians would agree. But that just shows how the other synoptic gospels have come to be read through the eyes of John. 
Yes, they say Jesus was the Son of God, but what does that mean in the first century? Most scholars say “Son of God” meant a man who’s anointed by God to rule the nations. David was the Son of God because he was the anointed king of Israel.>

In one of my very rare times i went to Mass at university I heard a long demolition of the Gospel of St Thomas but I understood nothing.

In almost complete ignorance I had trusted MR James's opinion on the apocryphal gospels "There is no question of any one's having excluded them from the New Testament : they have done that for themselves". He said that before the Gospel of Thomas and many other manuscripts were discovered in Egypt.

To be clear I do not propose we should think the Gospel of Thomas divinely inspired but we should understand the three synoptic Gospels much better than I did till I read Mrs Pagel's words this evening.

Of course my Biblical Unitarian Facebook friend Daisy has been arguing that the Bible does not say Jesus is God eloquently (and worryingly for an orthodox Christian) for years.

She does not believe even the Gospel of John teaches that Jesus is God. He is described as ‘The Anointed One’, the ‘Son of God’ - the Messiah, not, she says, God Almighty Himself.

1 comment:

  1. I watched a approx 20 episode great lectures I think on Jesus Christianity professor former Christian so I was skeptical he’d be fair although I no longer believe I’m more anti anti Christian than anti christ cuck
    He did what seemed ( without his level of expertise but at least a good catholic school education) to be an exhaustive and even handed respectful job. His main thesis was in fact the evolution of Jesus from man to part of the Tridentine godhead.
    Pagels book I read many decades ago not awful but she has a bit of an axe to grind. She did force me to look deeper into why some gospels did or didn’t make the cut. The choices made sense to the extent Christianity is less flaky than it might have been but a lot of that ties in with raising Jesus to co equal god. It doesn’t take a phd to notice something like that happened I can remember even in second grade asking the nuns why Jesus prays to god in a submissive way and is tempted by satan one example if he is god himself god bless those nuns patience w me

    ReplyDelete